29 January 2006

RGS girls pai kiah meh?

“When Straits Times columnist Chua Mui Hoong wrote that she would not send her (hypothetical) daughter to her alma mater, Raffles Girls' School (RGS), furious old girls wrote in to rebut what she said. Schools play a big role in shaping you, she wrote, and while RGS turns out confident, competent and competitive women, it does not encourage femininity and probably marriageability”

As I read this, I thought about all my married RGS friends, now with anak keliling pinggang and I had to burst out laughing. Is it true? Are RGS girls not feminine, stroppy, scary to men ergo not marriagable?

Apparently, many ex-RGS girls were baying for her blood and the article spawned discussions on blogs galore about school stereotypes. I managed to find the old article, read a couple of the discussions on the internet and my first reaction was disbelief that such stereotypes still exist. My second reaction was “Silly girl! You don’t have to take Technical what! They have Domestic Science then too, bodoh!” Personally, I would rather schlepp all the way to Swiss Cottage and make a wonky toothbrush holder rather than sit in absolute silence trying to sew a skirt or make rock buns.

I do have to say that I was not ultra feminine in school. It was rough and tumble all the way – my posse climbed rambutan trees, climbed gates after school hours, had short hair and dressed up as male characters in Taridra. In an all-girls school, it is inevitable that some of us would have to wear trousers and smudged our jawline with eyeliner to act out the male roles. And the short hair is practical – especially if you have to rush out of the door at 6.30 am in the morning to catch the bus or as in the case of the NPCC and NCC girls, had to march for hours under the sweltering sun.

I can’t speak for the rest but I don’t like acting the damsel in distress. One thing I learnt from being in RGS is that you can be as good as you want to be. I love the fact that in RGS, no one drilled into you that there are certain things that you cannot do because you are a girl.

Although now our tomboy ways are long gone, I would like to think that we came away with the strength of spirit and self belief that were instilled in those days. Yes, of course RGS girls valued achievement. We are competitive (just see my posting about Dikir Barat) and we are independent. And what is wrong with that? Personally I will absolutely burst with pride if Alia, one day, were to wear that blue pinafore.

7 comments:

yuRa said...

aaah .. baru boleh comment.

oh my God. it's like opening a can of worms!

it's ridiculous that as an ex-rgs girl she doesn't want to get her daughter educated there! her time there probably wasn't fulfilling enough, though i can't imagine why.

melayudilondon said...

ni confirmed mesti budak square kat tak masuk ECA. hahahaah. apa dia cakap RGS girls tak feminine, not patient etc. and RGS education not well rounded? Berderau darah ku. hahahaha dia support MGS lah - teringat aku Cikgu J cakap pasal MGS grils

yuRa said...

not well-rounded? dia tak tengok ke rgs dapat award for well-rounded education?? hmm..

mesti time kat rgs dia kena brainwash dengan cikgu j. hahah

Nani said...

I think, some of these columnists just write something annoying to get the reaction of readers, to see their response...There was also once Sumiko Tan (or Lee or whatever) wrote about how she hated to have little kids around her... I mean how.. I wonder, can their articles be approved for publication by their editors if their opinions are soooo shallow...

But, if they truly subscribe to whatever opinions they have expressed... Well, I think I feel really sorry for that Chua woman..and daughter(I read somewhere the daughter is imaginary, dunno how true)if she deprives her from being in RGS - an excellent school to achieve students' maximum potential.

She wasn't supported by any statistics indicating how feminine and marriageable RGS girls or the alumni are... so basically she's just swayed by her own stereotypelah... She's the sort who doesn't mix much with people like Shikin, Ayu and me heh heh so that's why her views are very narrow... pity her...

C'monlah...being confident, competent and competitive do not make you less of a woman or feminine or marriageable... and how does she measure feminine-ness...?

But what stays? That RGS is still the top school(take turns with RI) based on school ranking...(well at least based on the last academic and CCA school ranking..now that MOE has move away from academic ranking...they look at school processes now...even so, RGS is among the top, yeh yeh..:)

Nani said...

Oh...I missed that hypothetical thingie... surely if she really have a daughter, she'd probably not have such an opinion... Any parent with a sound mind who has a daughter who qualify wouldn't want her/his daughter to settle for second best... unless of course for some parents, for religious reasons or whatever send their children to the convent or methodist schools...or madrasah...

melayudilondon said...

kelakar kan? I believe she is being sensationalist lah. delibrately being provocative. mebbe kalau dah ada anak, mesti she sings a different tune. i still am in the frame of mind she probably not into ECA much lah. those who are heavily involved in ECA (macam kita ni) would know that not getting A1 in A Maths in not the end of the world. hahahahaah

yuRa said...

if that's true then, she's achieved her goal lah. she's made monkeys out of us for being so emotional about her article!

a'ah. i oso think her time at rgs was deprived of all the good things.